Italian Singers Speak Up: The Controversy Surrounding ‘Mafia’ Label

A British conductor has issued a heartfelt apology for likening singers at one of Italy’s most renowned opera houses to warring Mafia families. Edward Gardner, the principal conductor of the London Philharmonic Orchestra, faced potential defamation charges over his comments about the chorus members at Teatro San Carlo in Naples.

Last month, while speaking with The Times regarding a recent performance he had conducted at the venue, Gardner made an offhand comment: “The chorus is composed of two rival Mafia familieswho after one show ended up fighting each other and sending someone to A&E.”

In response, Teatro San Carlo issued a statement in which they expressed that Gardner wanted to “sincerely apologize to the members of the chorus at the San Carlo Opera House.” Gardner clarified his words: “Before I arrived in Naples, I was informed that two choir members had a public altercation just outside the theatre leading to one person being hospitalized. This surprised me greatly.”

He stressed, however, that he did not intend to imply that all of the chorus were Mafia associates and stated he is more than willing to retract his original assertion. “I want it clear,” Gardner elaborated, “that I have deep respect for and appreciation for the choir and its members. My appearance in Naples last summer was a meaningful experience which highlighted their talent, dedication, and hard work.”

Gardner added that he regrets any misunderstanding caused by his initial remarks: “I’ve personally experienced firsthand the professionalism and excellence of this chorus and want to make it absolutely clear how much I value and respect everyone involved.” His original statement infuriated Naples’ mayor who called them “very serious allegations that are completely unfounded.”